The sequel shifts the genre slightly, leaning harder into horror-fantasy elements. The resurrected Stagnetti isn't just a villain; he’s commanding a ghost ship and seeking an ancient power. The plot involves a quest for a scepter, zombie pirates, and mystical sea creatures. While the script often veers into melodrama, Evan Stone’s performance as Reynolds is the glue that holds it together. Stone plays the role with a knowing, Errol Flynn-esque wink. He understands the absurdity of the premise and leans into it, delivering a charismatic lead performance that is surprisingly watchable.